Credo ut Intelligam

Communion in the Hand? Pt. 1

with 2 comments

As sort of a Part Two to my last post… I wanted to dedicate a full post to “Communion in the Hand.”

I was born after the Council and never thought twice about this sort of thing.  I was taught to receive Holy Communion in the hand, creating a “throne” for our Lord to sit on His way to your mouth.  Now, I’m not saying that someone is bad for doing this… many people don’t even know the difference–like I didn’t.

A 2008 study from Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) at Georgetown University surveyed 1,007 self-identified adult Catholics in the United States on several points of the Faith.

Here is a PDF of the results from the study on the Mass and the Eucharist.  They found that 91% of people who attend Mass weekly believe in the Real Presence.  65% of who attend less than weekly, but at least once a month… and unsurprisingly, 40% of who attend a few times a year or less.

2008 cara georgetown study realpres


Even NCR (National Catholic Reporter aka “Fishwrap”, or as Father “Z”uhlsdorf calls it, National Schismatic Reporterweighed in on this issue, reporting the results of their 2011 survey.  Here is an excerpt of what they said:

We found that half of adult Catholics (50 percent) know the church’s teaching regarding the real presence and half do not. We also found that close to two-thirds of adult Catholics (63 percent) believe that “at the consecration during a Catholic Mass, the bread and wine really become the body and blood of Jesus Christ.” Therefore, more adult Catholics believe the statement than understand its source.

Whether or not you believe their assessment holds any water, it is definitely a trend in the Catholic Church in America–and likely throughout the world.

holy communion in hand

The question is, has communion in the hand affected the belief of the Real Presence?

No one can deny that we are visual creatures.  We can recognize something seemingly sacred by observing the actions of other people… receiving the Eucharist on your knees and on the tongue is a powerful visual of the belief in the sacredness of the Eucharist.

On the other hand, receiving the Eucharist in the hand and popping it in your mouth as you walk away from the clergyman or (ugh) EMHC doesn’t quite send the same message.

Can the Eucharist be reverently received in the hand?  Surely.  That is how I was taught and received Jesus in the Eucharist for years… but did I hold the same sacredness for it–and did I fully grasp what I was receiving?  Shamefully, no, I didn’t.  I think more appropriately in this case than ever, actions speak louder than words.

Lex Orandi, Lex Credendi, Lex Vivendi.

As we Worship, So we Believe, So we Live

How we worship is how we believe, which affects how we live.

If we approach and receive the Blessed Sacrament like a Protestant approaches their version(s) of [originally Catholic] communion, in which they do not believe that Jesus is present Body and Soul in the Eucharist, then we will believe in that manner.

It’s as simple as that.

Enjoy some (formerly videos on the subject.


“Holy Communion in the Hand”

“Kneel before God!”

Written by Daniel Brooks

March 20th, 2013 at 11:59 am

Posted in Eucharist,Vatican II

2 Responses to 'Communion in the Hand? Pt. 1'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Communion in the Hand? Pt. 1'.

  1. Hi Just read your article on Communion in the Hand.
    I found an Article a while ago about the Discussion with Pope Paul V1 and his Bishops on this subject.
    The Pope decided to have a vote on whether the Bishops wanted the Faithful to receive the communion on the tongue or in the Hand. The majority of the Bishops voted against Communion in the Hand as it took away from the Sacredness of The Eucharit. The Pope agreed and it was made Law.
    Some of the Bishops had already began the practice in their Dioceses of giving Communion in the hand, so a paragraph allowing this continuence because it had already begun was inserted into the Decree.
    Sadly those Bishops who were for Communion in the Hand obviously decided to bring in the Practice after the Decree unknown to the Faithful in their Dioceses. To this day it has continued.
    Pope John Paul 11 Banned Communion in the Hand in the Vatican (I think) in 2000


    1 May 13 at 1:21 pm

  2. Thanks for reading. Yes you’re absolutely right… it began as an abuse. I read about the origins of Communion in the Hand in the 20th century from a book called “Communion In The Hand Documents And History.” I bought the book but just now using a search engine found it online… I don’t know if the full book is here, though. Definitely worth a look!
    Communion in the Hand – Documents and History

    I would like to inform Catholics about this issue, but not sure how to go about doing it. There are a lot of clergy that totally frown on kneeling and accepting the Eucharist on the tongue… as if when we accept our Lord in the Eucharist as we should, on our knees, we are being “overly pious” and “Pharisaical.” I haven’t met any clergy in my own diocese like this but have while travelling. Anyway, I think more light is being shed on this issue as time goes by.

    Daniel Brooks

    14 May 13 at 1:50 pm

Leave a Reply

× three = 15